May 26, 2011

Horse 1194 - Would NFL Be Safer Without Helmets?

I've just been watching the first State of Origin Rugby League match between NSW and Queensland for 2011 and was wondering about this though experiment proposed by the Wall Street Journal in 2009; namely:

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704402404574527881984299454.html
This football season, the debate about head injuries has reached a critical mass. Startling research has been unveiled. Maudlin headlines have been written. Congress called a hearing on the subject last month.
...
But before the debate goes any further, there's a fundamental question that needs to be investigated. Why do football players wear helmets in the first place? And more important, could the helmets be part of the problem?

Watching the Rugby League tonight, it was startlingly obvious to me that the hits taken by players in a Rugby League match are nowhere near as rough as they are in a game of NFL, and I tend to wonder if helmets are part of the problem.
I also find it a little curious that the NFL season only lasts 17-weeks, and the matches are only 60 minutes of actual game time, as opposed to 80 minutes in a game of Rugby League and 120 minutes in an Australian Rules Football match.

The British Medical Association came to the conclusion in one of their reports, that the risk of serious injury and death caused by head trauma was actually lower in the days of bare-knuckle boxing. Because boxers would feel their own punches more without gloves they'd tend not to hit as hard. There are reports of prizefights lasting beyond the 6 hour mark. The link is below:
http://www.bma.org/ap.nsf/AttachmentsByTitle/PDFboxingdebate/$FILE/TheBoxingDebate.pdf

Then there is the curious tale of the Munich Taxicab Experiment, in which half of a fleet of taxicabs were fitted with ABS and half not. The drivers were then let loose but not told which cabs they had.


Among a total of 747 accidents incurred by the company's taxis during that period, the involvement rate of the ABS vehicles was not lower, but slightly higher,
...
Subsequent analysis of the rating scales showed that drivers of cabs with ABS made sharper turns in curves, were less accurate in their lane-holding behaviour, proceeded at a shorter forward sight distance, made more poorly adjusted merging manoeuvres and created more "traffic conflicts".
http://psyc.queensu.ca/target/chapter07.html

I'm wondering then, if NFL players didn't have helmets on, whether they'd be as likely to use their heads as battering rams the way they can do now, and whether or not the game would be made safer as a result?

This idea I imagine falls into the same sorts of questions as Risk Compensation, Risk Homeostasis and the Peltzman Effect, all of which are more to do with insurance risk questions than anything else, but it's still a good question.

Would NFL Be Safer Without Helmets? I wonder.

May 25, 2011

Horse 1193 - Geek Pride Day - Bonus Post

1. Is Unity and is therefore interesting.

2. Is the only even Prime number and is therefore interesting.

3. Is both Prime and a Triangular number and is therefore interesting.

4. Is a square number and is therefore interesting.

5. Is a Prime number and is therefore interesting.

6. Is a Triangular number and is therefore interesting.

7. Is a Prime number and is therefore interesting.

8. Is a Cubic number and is therefore interesting.

9. Is a square number and is therefore interesting.

10. Is a Triangular number and is therefore interesting.

11. Is a Prime number and is therefore interesting.

12. Is the first Abundant number and is therefore interesting.

13. Is a Prime number and is therefore interesting.

BUT

14 has nothing particular interesting about it at all. 14 is a boring boring number. Thierry Henry played in the 14 kit for Arsenal, which is a boring boring team and he is a boring boring player.
If 14 is so boring, does that make it interesting? I think not. 14 you are a boring boring number. Go and play with the other boring numbers.

Horse 1192 - The Use of Syrup in Coffee

Yesterday my boss went for a jaunt into the City where we had a meeting and during the course of the meeting we went to a certain franchise coffee house, where five out of the six of us had coffee with added syrup except me who ordered my usual "long black". Nobody else seemed to mind about the quality of their coffee, but mine was utterly horrid. As a result of this, there is only one conclusion that I can come up with - This franchise coffee house uses rubbish coffee but masks it with syrupy badness.

I can see a parallel with this and the reasons (I suspect), for the use of a lot of spices in certain kinds of cooking. If meat had gone off or was beginning to turn, by spicing the meat to the point of utter ridiculousness, people could no longer taste that the meat had gone off.
Coffee is made from the seeds or pit in the middle of the fruit of the coffee plant, technically coffee is a cherry of sorts so I suspect that like every other fruit, that if it is left out for a long time, it's probably likely to go bad.

There might be some degree of truth that maybe this particular franchise coffee house either keeps its coffee in storage for a longer time, or it could also be the case that in the chase for ever greater profits, they're simply using a cheaper grade of coffee.
I already object to coffee houses milking and frothing up coffee in an effort to justify charging so much for their coffee. Adding syrup is just extra addition which can be marked up 500%, thus sending even more money into the hands of Franchise Coffee House™ Inc.

One thing I found in the United States was that because of the prevalence of Franchise Coffee House™ Inc. many smaller operators simply couldn't play the margins any more and shut down. Some hotels even boasted about having Franchise Coffee House™ Inc. either on their premises or even in the room. Admittedly I never stayed in any of these hotels, but I found generally that either because most of the coffee in the United States was drip coffee (which itself should be a crime), or Rival Franchise Coffee House™ Inc., one could never find a decent cup of coffee anywhere.

I have travelled through France and Italy and I can tell you from first hand experience, that the best coffee (and even from poor quality beans to begin with) is made by baristas who have turned it into an art. Even in the UK, you can still find greasy spoons where the coffee might not be world class but the atmosphere is cosy and warm instead of being blasted with the latest chart entry.

There is hope though. Franchise Coffee House™ Inc. closed two-thirds of its "stores" in Australia with some market analysts citing that they failed to understand the "European coffee culture" in Australia. I however think that the reason is far more obvious than this. The point being that if you sell a product which is horrid, then less people will want to buy it in the first place.

May 22, 2011

Horse 1191 - OneHD's Coverage of Formula One... or Rather Not.

In Horse 1187 I complained that One HD's coverage of Formula One online was woefully inadequate. At the next GP in Spain the coverage completely dropped out and didn't restart until lap 8, meaning that if you were relying on the online stream for live coverage, you got diddly-squat and missed the start.

In the meantime, I was following Twitter and counting the number of complaints that were sent to the @OneHD twitter account. At the time of this posting, we were up to 2523 tweets all singing together in their general grumpiness about the poor TV coverage.

It also made me think about how badly this reflects on OneHD's main "sponsors" of the F1 coverage. Vodafone are trying to push their Infinite 45 plan, and there are adverts for Mercedes-Benz online. Now admittedly I can't afford a Mercedes-Benz so I won't be buying one of those, but just suppose you were trying to use the "Desire HTC" on Vodafon's Infinite 45 plan to watch the Formula One coverage, just what do you think you would have seen for the those first 8 laps of the race? NOTHING.

I have resigned myself to the fact that if I want to watch Formula One, for yet another season, it's not going to be live because I will be forced to watch it on Channel 10 after they play NCIS, Hawaii-Five-O, and Masterchef. But at least I can say this...

Because of you One HD and your owners Channel 10, I will deliberately not consider Vodafone for my next mobile phone and will cancel my existing phone contract. I will also delierately try to avoid NCIS, Hawaii-Five-O, and Masterchef out of spite and sincerely hope that the 2012 season of Formula One goes to someone part way compotent like Channel 7 or Channel 9.
How was it that in 1987 we could see all 16 races LIVE but in 2011 we can't manage to see any at all?

I'll leave you to ponder that whilst I watch Doctor Who on ABC iView. Heck even the ABC can live stream ABC News 24 without any problems.

May 18, 2011

Horse 1190 - Round And Round

http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/column-8/column-8-20110516-1epu1.html
"Does anyone know what the direction of travel around a circle was called before clock faces were invented?" asks Nigel Hancock, of Castle Hill. "The reason I ask this is I suspect it will have to be resurrected shortly, as Gen Y's younger siblings (Gen Z?) have no idea what clockwise and anti-clockwise mean in the digital age."


The word for clockwise before clocks were invented perhaps not surprisingly was "Sunwise". That little word also gives you a hint as to why clocks go in that direction in the first place.

If you are living in the Northern Hemisphere as the majority of conquering civilisations were, then if you were to erect a sundial, you'd notice that the sun which rises in the East sweeps a trail through the Southern portion of the skies before settling in the West. - East. South. West.
Like wise the shadow which is always going to be in the opposite direction of the light source (the sun) describes a path from the West, points to the North before trailling off to the East. - West. North. East.

In both cases, the light source and the shadows move in the same direction of travel around the central point of the compass in a sunwise direction.
If you were going to build a machine that mechanically pointed to the sun on its journey across the sky so that you could tell time by it, then quite naturally it would mimic the sun and shadows and also travel in a sunwise direction.
The word clock itself probably derives from the Celtic world "clocca" which means a "bell", being the messenger from the mechanical govenor of time.

If you wanted a word to describe something that went the other way to the sun, it would be obvious to call it something that meant "the other way".
The word for the other way in English before the invention of the clock is the word "Widdershins", which comes to us via Lowland Scots and Low German. The Low German word "widersinnig" means "against sense" and are good cognates.

I wanted to confirm this and so I took a trip down to a park near where I work, and presumed that because I live in the Southern Hemisphere, that the sundial would go in the opposite direction to the Northern Hemisphere because the sun travels East, North, west, and that the numbers would be arranged in a Widdershins direction. Lo and behold, they are.

Of course the obvious counter argument to the Column 8 problem is simply to give the younger generations normal watches. Digital Watches have existed since 1972 and they haven't displaced analogue watches at all.

May 17, 2011

Horse 1189 - The Last Day Arrives

This then is the state of play going into the last round of the season:

44 - Sunderland (safe)

40 - Blackburn Rovers (playing Wolves)
40 - Wolverhampton Wanderers (playing Blackburn)
39 - Birmingham City (playing Spurs)
------
39 - Blackpool (playing Man Utd)
39 - Wigan Athletic (playing Stoke)
33 - West Ham Utd (gone)

If either Blackburn or Wolves win their match against each other, then they're safe, so you can expect this encounter to be spiteful. If in the event that they draw with each other, they'd both go to 41 points and it is technically possible that if Birmingham, Blackpool and Wigan all win, then those three clubs would end on 42 and they'd both be relegated.
For both Blackburn and Wolverhampton, a win guarantees survival.

Because Birmingham, Blackpool and Wigan are all on 39 points, then even a win might not ensure survival because if all three win and there isn't a draw in the Blackburn-Wolves game, then one of them would be relegated.

It would come down to goal difference if they ended up on the same number of points, so you'd expect that they'd all want to go out and smash as many goals as they possibly could. Even in the event that they somehow all miraculously ended up equal on goal difference, then Blackpool would end with 11 wins as opposed to 9 for both Birmingham and Wigan. As for what happens beyond that, I simply do not know.


Birmingham will be playing Tottenham away at White Hart but Tottenham themselves will be pushing to play as hard as they possibly can because if they win, they'll be guaranteed a spot in next season's Europa League.

Wigan will be travelling to the Britannia Stadium in Stoke-on-Trent to play Stoke City but Stoke who have already qualified for the Europa League because they made through to the FA Cup Final (and Manchester City were already qualified for the Champions League), don't really need to worry about the match at all and so this could very well be the easiest of the matches of those in trouble.

Blackpool are faced with the daunting task of facing newly crowned champions Manchester United at Old Trafford. I think that it's fair to say that if Blackpool win against Man United, then they've earned their right to stay in the top flight.

Bizarrely because England has earned an extra spot in the Europa League under the "Fair Play" regulations, it means that Blackpool could be playing in Europe because of their on-field discipline... if only that could be said of the manager Ian Holloway. Though to be fair Blackpool has been on the end of the most decisions brought before the "Dubious Goals Committee" of the FA, so perhaps Olly does have reason to flip his lid every 25 seconds... or maybe not.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/football/teams/blackpool/8517677/Ian-Holloways-antics-could-rob-Blackpool-of-Europa-League-spot.html

Meanwhile at West Ham...

The bats have left the bell tower, the victims have been bled,
Red velvet lines the black box,
Bela Lugosi's deeeead... Bela Lugosi's dead (I'll 'ave 'is chips then) Bela Lugosi's deeeead!
 

Mind you, I do think that the way former West Ham manager Avram Grant was sacked was rather a bit callous. He hadn't even left the players' tunnel and was forced to front a media scrum. They were on that like a pack of wild dogs on a three legged cat!

http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/2011/may/15/avram-grant-sacked-west-ham-united-manager

May 11, 2011

Margaret Thatcher and Mr Whippy

From the Mr Whippy Ice Cream website:


http://www.mrwhippyicecream.co.uk/the-history-of-ice-cream/

One important development in the 20th century was the introduction of soft ice cream (like Mr Whippy uses!). A chemical research team in Britain (of which a young Margaret Thatcher was a member) discovered a method of doubling the amount of air in ice cream, which allowed manufacturers to use less of the actual ingredients, thereby reducing costs. 
...
Before become a member of parliament,  former British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher whilst working as a research chemist for J.Lyons & Co and developing emulsifiers, quite literally found a way OF TAKING ICE CREAM FROM CHILDREN.

May 10, 2011

Horse 1188 - The Push for Scottish Independence

http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2011/may/08/scotland-independence-vote-financial-autonomy
Alex Salmond is prepared to compromise on the Scottish independence referendum by including an extra question on giving Holyrood much greater financial freedom while remaining part of the UK.
The Scottish first minister said on Sunday he would talk to other parties about offering the voters a second choice known as "fiscal autonomy" within the UK, rather than a straight yes or no vote on Scotland moving to complete independence.

I was directed to this article in The Grauniad (sic), and was asked what Horse's opinion on Scottish Independance is. There are lots of lots of issues bound up with this; so I'll try to unpack them all, but my general overview is that if it is the will of the people to dissolve the United Kingdom, then I see no reason why legally they should not be allowed to.

A Brief History:
Scotland and England being two separate and very distinct countries have occupied the island of Great Britain (which is also the largest island within the British Isles) nominally from about the Dark Ages onwards.
The two nations often fought nasty wars against each other before begrudingly they were united via a personal "Union of the Crowns" under James VI of Scotland who became James I of England. They were formally united by act of law with the Acts of Union 1707.

Technically the current Crown as a legal entity and currently vested in the person of Queen Elizabeth II, is firstly a Scottish and secondly an English legal fiction.
To repeal the relevant acts of Union which I think would at least include the 1707 and 1800 Acts, would render Scotland to that of a seperate realm equal to that in status of other nations within the broader context of the Commonwealth like Canada, Australia and New Zealand.
The Crown would still be the legal entity but instead of shared union between Scotland and England, Scotland would become the Kingdom of Scotland within it's own right; more often styled as simply Scotland or perhaps the Dominion of Scotland.

First Reason for Scottish Independence - Money:
There are of course the usual patriotic reasons for Scotland to declare itself as Independent, what with Scotland having it's own national identity etcetera, etcetera, etcetera, and whilst those reasons are all good and proper, it strikes me that there is a far more consequential reason at play here - Whitehall.

The British Government which is based in London, has in the past made the claim that because of higher unemployment rates in Scotland, that Whitehall effectively "subsidses" the people of Scotland. London is of course one of the great trading captials of the world and it does have a tendancy to suck in investment from the rest of the UK generally, but it also happens to suck in an awful lot of taxation.



The Scottish National Party although formed in 1934, really came to prominence in the 1974 General Election with its "It's Scotland's Oil" campaign. Following the 1973 Oil Crisis, the claim was made that had had Scotland been an economic entity it its own right, then it should have been entitled to the increased royalties from the sale of North Sea Oil.

http://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/1999/1126/contents/made

If you read through the particulars of the "The Scottish Adjacent Waters Boundaries Order 1999" and "The English Adjacent Waters Boundaries Order 1999", then technically 95% of all so-called "British" oil reserves fall within Scottish Waters.
Assuming Scotland was to become independent, then there'd probably be a set of international rulings; probably at the International Court of Justice in The Hague and it would confirm existing legal boundaries.
Scotland would then be legitimately entitled to the royalties from the sale of oil, which even in 1974 was seen as dangerous.


http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/scotland/4303750.stm
Professor McCrone argued that the economy of an independent Scotland, properly managed, would "tend to be in chronic surplus to a quite embarrassing degree".
"Its currency would become the hardest in Europe, with the exception perhaps of the Norwegian kroner," he wrote.

I imagine that all of the royalties from oil revenue going to Holyrood rather than Whitehall would be rather embarassing. I suppose that Whitehall could take solace in the fact that it wouldn't be "subsidsing" the people of Scotland any more.
And with potentially such a strong currency north of the border with the Scottish Pound, would those investment funds that would have settled in the City of London then find abode in the financial district of Edinburgh? The potential for Scotland to gain is quite considerable and perhaps it should have the British Parliament feeling nervous.



Second Reason for Scottish Independence - Money:

Perhaps the push for Britain to join the common currency has faded now, but not long after the creation of the hard currency in 2002, there were suggestions that the UK was going to adopt the Euro and abandon the Pound Sterling. This however would have had other implications.

There used to be a requirement in the UK in order to prevent a "run" on the banks, that the banks were to hold on reserve a certain percentage of customer's funds either stored as cash, or on deposit with the Bank of England. This was known as the Cash Reserve Ratio and was as high as 20% during the late 1960s, though it was progressively lowered to about 3% by the late 1990s before becoming entirely voluntary.
Scottish Banks because they operated under a slightly different set of regulations within Scots law, meant that instead of holding currency either stored on-site or with the Bank of England, could hold it as phyisical currency in the hands of the public.
If you move north of the border and into Scotland, you'll find banknotes issued and printed by the Bank of Scotland, Royal Bank of Scotland and Clydesdale Bank. There also used to be banknotes issued by British Linen Bank and Union Bank of Scotland.


http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/scotland/656600.stm
Scotland's three banks will be banned from issuing their own notes if the UK joins the single currency, according to a European Central Bank committee.
The Frankfurt-based bank believes that notes issued by Scottish commercial banks are not legal tender and that their continued use would be illegal under European law.

If the UK was to adopt the Euro and abandon the Pound Sterling, then because the European Central Bank refused to allow any other entity other that national central banks to issue currency, then the Scottish banks would have been forced to not only stop issuing currency, but also to buy back the currency in the hands of the public.
Potentially this would have caused massive runs on the banking system in Scotland but not because of a loss of confidence as is usually the case but by operation of the law itself.

<><><><><>

I really don't think that the reasons for the SNP's push for Scottish Independance are mainly to do with a sense of nationalism. Scots generally have a reputation for being practical people who have invented all sorts of things and found great engineering solutions but they also have a reputation for being fiercely tight with money.
Over the past 10 years we've seen Britain go off to war in the Middle East, accusations of grift and rorts in Whitehall (including using public money to build Duck Houses and moats), and perhaps most frightening for the people of Scotland, the "Global Financial Crisis" of 2008-2010 and the Blue Monday Crash of 2009 when the RBS annouced the biggest corporate losses in British history resulting in the share price falling by 67% in a day.

If Scotland's destiny is to be continued to be tied to the UK, then so be it. If Scotland wishes to again stand as a separate nation, then it's probably got more to do with a sense of financial independence from London more than anything else. And instead of it being as the result of a struggle under an oppressive regieme, it will have been the the result of a 30-80 year slow rumble.

At very least it would give Neil Oliver of "A History of Scotland" and "Coast" fame, the chance to make another documentary series.  However this time around, he could walk around inside parliament buildings and grand banking halls instead of windswept moors and hillsides...

... I feel ever so sorry for him sometimes. I hope that he gets to go inside and have a nice warm cup of cocoa by the fire.

May 09, 2011

Horse 1187 - OneHD's Coverage of Formula One

In this age of advancements, the relentless march of technology should in theory make our lives better. In some cases it has but if you happen to be a Formula One fan, then I'd say that it was probably better to be living in the 1980s.
In the UK and then in Australia, F1 coverage was provided by the BBC and Channel 9. The BBC of course bought their feeds from the local broadcaster, and Channel 9 bought the BBC production.

Nice. Simple.

Now that we've reached the days of digital broadcasting, things have gone totally haywire.

One started broadcasting on Digital TV, and for early adopters of the technology who'd gone out and bought a digital TV, that was fine. Then Network Ten shifted One to HD only once they started their sister station 11.
I could very easily solve the problem buy buying a set-top box, but what is the point of buying a set-top box to watch digital television on a digital television?
I then went and made the switch to the so-called "Live Streaming" on the One HD website, but so-far in the 2011 season, the website has failed catastrophically in four from four races.

To add insult to injury, because OneHD falls under the "Multi-Channel" provisions of the AMCA guide under clause 5.10 of the regulations for commercial television, they are exempt from limits on the amount of advertising per hour.

During the Turkish GP when the OneHD server wasn't dead (for 31 of 58 laps) they then did their best to bombard you with adverts.
This means that if you were watching the 2011 Turkish GP on the OneHD website, then out of the total race time of 1hr 30mins 17sec, you would have only seen a paltry 42mins 22sec.

What I find almost unbelievable is that DSTV on their "SuperSport" channel in Sudan got the whole race with no ads and no server fails.
So how about that OneHD? Even people in Darfur, Sudan which was plagued with civil war still got a better F1 coverage than people in Australia.

So OneHD, I think that that would be rather embarrassing for you... seriously.

May 06, 2011

Horse 1186 - Clegg's Next Steps

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-13303862
Lord Ashdown said he believed that Mr Cameron had made a private agreement with Mr Clegg about the way the fight over the future of the electoral system would be conducted, and there had been a "breach of faith".
He said: "If the Conservative party funds to the level of 99% a campaign whose central theme is to denigrate and destroy our leader, there are consequences for that."

Liberal Democrat leader Nick Clegg I feel is at the crossroads of not only his political career but possibly that of the party itself. The referendum to bring in the Alternative Vote will either represents what is both a wasted opportunity and indeed the very death knell of the party, or perhaps a chance for rebirth and relevance.

Essentially during the AV referendum lead in, the "No" Campaign was being funded by the Conservative Party. The actual campaign itself was for the most part a series of half-truths and straight out lies:

http://www.newstatesman.com/blogs/the-staggers/2011/05/campaign-figure-blunkett
Today's Times (£) quotes David Blunkett, the former Labour home secretary, admitting that the No campaign's figure putting the cost of AV at £250m was "made up". He said:
"We are in the middle of an election campaign. People in elections use made-up figures. I have never used the £250m figure. It [AV] would undoubtedly cost more but I have used an extra £90m."
-----
The Electoral Commission said at the time that it was powerless to do anything, as electoral law covers false claims against candidates, but referendums have none.

Then of course there is the comment from PM Cameron himself, which I first heard on the BBC World Service, but was reprinted in The Telegraph:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/av-referendum/8491800/AV-The-No-Campaign-in-quotes.html
“It’s about what you feel in your gut – about the values you hold dear and the beliefs you instinctively have. And I just feel it, in my gut, that AV is wrong"
- David Cameron, British PM, 05/05/11

There is of course a very good reason why Mr Cameron feels it in his gut that AV is wrong, because as a Tory it is.
If we look at British Elections going all the way back until roughly the formation of the current party political system within the parliament, there have only been two Prime Ministers who weren't Tories who not only went the full term but were returned to power as the sitting Prime Minister. One was Tony Blair who won in 1997, 2001 and 2006 and the other was the 3rd Viscount Palmerston, who won the 1859 and 1865 elections.
Cameron quite rightly assumes that if the British Public were actually allowed to be given a more democratic system to elect their parliament with, then that would effectively spell the end of the normalcy of Tory dominated politics in the UK, which is a tradition which extends back to 1762.

So then, if Cameron and the Tories have acted in bad faith, what is open the Nick Clegg and the LibDems?

The first answer might be to formally breakup the coalition and try to form government with Labour. The problem is that if you add Labour's 258 to the LibDem's 57, you only get 315 which is 11 short of the 326 required to form government.
Of course you could always ask the Scottish National Party, Sinn Féin, Plaid Cymru and the Social Democratic and Labour Party to try and help you and between them they'd all spill to 337 which is fine, but that would be like trying to organise the heads of a Hydra.

The second answer would be to run a Vote of No Confidence. If that were to happen, then it would probably most likely carry and there'd be another General Election but this time around the polls might be either favourable or against the LibDems, so the gamble might not be worth it.

The third option for Clegg is this:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-13303885
Nick Clegg is facing calls from the party's local government chiefs to step down as leader after heavy losses in the English council elections.
Gary Long, ousted party leader on Nottingham City Council, said he must quit immediately, while Ken Ball, party leader on Chorley council, said he had "let the party down".

Ultimately what what that prove though? That the Tories were right?

If the "Alternative Vote is too difficult to understand" as the Tories have suggested throughout the campaign, and Australians have been using a similar system to select Members of Parliament for 80 years, then may the Tories are correct...

... The Great British Public really are stupid thickos, and it's a good thing too otherwise we'd have oiks running the country.

May 05, 2011

Horse 1185 - Thirty-Seven

I went online looking for some Nescafe Blend 37, wondering if I could import it to tell in there was a difference between it and what is sold in Australia as Nescafe Gold. There is an obvious difference between Blend 43 and Blend 37. 37 has a more bitter yet richer taste to it and I think is a superior blend of coffee.
Nevertheless, a look at Nescafe's own website made me somewhat suspicious:

http://www.nescafe.co.uk/CoffeeCupboard/everyday-choice/nescaf-blend-37
When his co-driver didn’t show up, Didier Cambreson refused to withdraw and simply completed the 1937 Le Mans single-handed. Driving car number 37, and pausing only for coffee breaks, he finished an impressive 37th. What else could we name the coffee that kept him on track?
- as at 5th May, 2011

Update: 
 http://www.nescafe.co.uk/product_details_en_co_uk.axcms?Id=24
When his co-driver didn’t show up, Didier Cambreson refused to withdraw and simply completed the 1937 Le Mans single-handed. Driving car number 37, and pausing only for coffee breaks, he finished an impressive 37th. What else could we name the coffee that kept him on track? Blend 37 has a full-bodied, rugged intensity that we love. Dark roasted to a rich nuttiness with hints of toasted cereal and a smooth, malty caramel finish.
- as at 18th Apr, 2012

However if search back through the record I find that:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1937_24_Hours_of_Le_Mans
The car numbered 37 in 1937, finished in 5th place, was an Aston Martin 1½ Ulster and piloted by J.M. Skeffington and R.C. Murton-Neale. The only places I've managed to find mention of Didier Cambreson whoever he is, seems to be in connected with Nescafe Blend 37. Could it be that Mr Cambreson has been made up? Is he just an invention? A fabrication? A fib?

Finding a photograph of the actual Aston Martin proved difficult, but it appears as though there have been  various models made of it, including a Scalextric variant from about 2002. This photo however is just of one of the models:


I then remembered that there had been some Renaults in the British Touring Car Championship in the late 1990s bearing the number 37.


One person who is not a fabrication or a fib is two times BTCC Champion Jason Plato. For three seasons Nescafe Blend 37 sponsored the Renault BTCC effort of which Plato was a part. Other drivers of the green Blend 37 Renaults were Alain Menu, Tommy Rustad and Jean-Christophe Boullion.


Boullion drove for part of the 1995 Formula One season for Sauber and has competed at Le Mans 11 times, his best result being a third in 2007. In the BTCC he did drive the number 37 Renault, but he didn't really have a good season in 1999 and left after the Renault team folded later that year.

I then wondered where else Nescafe could have decided to take the number 37 from and thought that it might be from Paddy Hopkirk's giant killing Mini Cooper S:


Paddy Hopkirk and Henry Liddon took the Mini (reg 33 EJB) to victory in the 1964 Monte Carlo Rally. This 1071cc car with a paltry 70bhp, probably made the establishment very scared indeed. In 1965 Timo Mäkinen and Paul Easter repeated the win and would have come 1-2-3 in 1966 but the French organisers had to invent the excuse that the cars had lights that were too bright. In 1967 Rauno Aaltonen and Henry Liddon but by that stage The Monte was just another rally and its lustre had been lost.

MINI are desperately trying to cash in on the legend and will sell you a set of "37" decals for your new MINI, and in this year's WRC will again run the number 37 on one of their cars.



Liverpool defender and all around hard man, Martin Skrtel plays in the number 37 kit.
Various "facts" have been written about Martin Skrtel including:
- Martin Skrtel doesn't read books. He stares them down until he gets the information he wants.
- He once ate an entire bottle of sleeping pills. They made him blink.
- Martin Skrtel eats nails for breakfast.
- Martin Skrtel was once in a knife fight, and the knife lost.


I wonder if Nescafe would consider sponsoring Martin Skrtel. Certainly if you saw him coming towards you in a dark alley you'd want to stay awake, you might even be afraid to ever fall asleep again. Every night the Bogieman checks under his bed for Martin Skrtel...



Adam Goodes is a dual Brownlow Medallist and has played in the Australian side on four occasions. Goodes is one of those players who takes nonsense from no-one and on occasion has been charged with striking. He was part of the 2005 Sydney Swans Premiership side and if it wasn't for Mad Bad Barry Hall would have been captain.
The thing with Goodes is that he will never be given the accolades that he deserves. He'll never be the best Full-Forward, Winger or Full-Back of all time because as probably the only truly complete utility player the AFL has ever seen, he can play any and every position on the park excellently. I bet if they invented a cloning machine and played 18 Adam Goodes at once, the team would beat Geelong 35.9.219 to 0.1.1 and even then Geelong would only score the behind because Goodesy felt sorry for them.

The truth is that I have no idea why Nescafe chose the number 37 for that particular blend of coffee. I'll bet that the truth is ludicrously mundane and is as simple as it being just a batch number, rather like the original Boeing 707 being called "707" because the Boeing marketing department decided "707" was "a bit catchier" than the number "700".

May 03, 2011

Horse 1183a - Addenda

"I mourn the loss of thousands of precious lives, but I will not rejoice in the death of one, not even an enemy."
- Martin Luther King, Jr

"Say to them, ‘As surely as I live, declares the Sovereign LORD, I take no pleasure in the death of the wicked, but rather that they turn from their ways and live. Turn! Turn from your evil ways!"
- Ezekiel 33:11

May 02, 2011

Horse 1183 - The Death of Bin Laden... Rejoicing?

The news that flashed around the world at great speed came to my knowledge just as I was returning from lunch today. US President Obama of course used this as a platform for American truimphalism and mentioned phrases to do with moving forwards to the task ahead. It was all incredibly typical.

What I was not expecting was reports coming in via the BBC World Service, being relayed via Twitter and Farcebook (sic) and even across forums which I visit of rejoicing and almost jubilation at the death of Osama Bin Laden and yet somehow this didn't seem to sit right with me.


Four days ago with the wedding of Prince William and Princess Kate, we were treated to scenes of great pomp and circumstance and quite rightly so, as this was after all the wedding of the future King of the United Kingdom and the other Commonwealth Realms. This however was met with a degree of apathy as well as celebration in both the UK and Australia.

To me this represents some sort of contrast. On one hand we have people who are celebrating an event which is supposed to be a time for celebration being met with apathy, yet on the other we have the killing of a man (albeit one who was a scoundrel and really quite horrible) being met with a great deal of celebration. To be sure I think that the world is probably a marginally safer place for his passing, but to rejoice at someone's death?

If this is perhaps seated in the motives of revenge, then perhaps a review of the facts is in order.
About 3000 people died all up in the terrorist attacks on Sep 11, 2011. It is estimated that in the ten years since, between 34,000-38,000 Taliban & insurgents have been killed with a further 14,000-30,000 civilians who have also perished. If revenge seeks a blood payment under the laws of exact retribution, then surely that payment has been forcibly taken from anywhere between sixteen and twenty-two times over. Does that require rejoicing over the fact that the deal is decided unfair?

The more I think about this, I increasingly uneasy about rejoicing over the death of this man. We've seen ten years of bloody and stupid conflict; involving people who really should not have had any part in this at all. I think that the best thing that could happen at this point is that the desert flowers should forth their tender shoots of hope, the oaks should grow gracefully and the earth should remember him not, but to start rejoicing is a nasty nasty response considering the price which has been paid.

Horse 1182 - No 2 AV revisited again

I have a piqued interest in the referendum in the UK on May 5, but mainly because of what appears to be a "No" campaign based around half-truths and 3/4 lies.

Consider this advert:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E19pmc-Jhpo&feature=player_detailpage

I think it's curious that the purple votes get transferred to only three of the remaining four candidates. Surely the only way this would happen is if the fifth candidate was of a completely different ideology to the first candidate.
At any rate, the graphic still shows that the winning second candidate still ended up with 50% of the vote; therefore was still the choice of at least 50% of the voters.

There is a slightly odd thing about this as well. Although this advert has tried to demonise BNP voters, it still doesn't manage to negate the fact that they are in fact part of the electorate. What would happen for instance if the first or second canidate was a so-called "extremist"? Does that also invalidate this theory?

I find it intriguing that for the entire of the No2AV Campaign's videos, this delightful message appears: "Adding comments has been disabled for this video."
Does this mean to say that people not having a say and adding to the discussion is now more democratic? I'm afraid I don't understand that one myself.

David Gower's comments are also equally bizarre:

http://www.youtube.com/user/officialNO2AV#p/u/12/1ivpx21rmNM

Mr Gower, I would like to point out the obvious that in a game of cricket, there are only two sides. The side that wins is the team with the most runs. You don't have five or six teams all competing in a match; therefore your little analogy breaks down instantly.

The Alternative Voting system is akin to instant run off voting. If you were to do a comparison with the game of cricket, then the closest analogy (which is also highly faulty) would be something like the knockout stages of the world cup, where the winners go onto the next round. The Alternative Voting system acts as a paper implementation of an instant run-off voting system. No-one seems to have in Ireland in using the instant run-off voting system for electing the President of Ireland, and even more bizarre is that it is also employed to elect hereditary peers for the British House of Lords.
http://www.parliament.uk/documents/lords-information-office/holnotice20100601.pdf

I find it strange that in particular Baroness Sayeeda Warsi who was appointed to the House of Lords and therefore was not elected herself, leads the No Campaign when the House of Lords uses this system to appoint other Lords.

Again this supposed figure which has been pulled out of seemingly nowhere that 60% of Australians don't want the AV system has been wheeled out again. Where did this come from? I haven't seen any Newspoll, Galaxy Poll or AC Neilsen poll which verifies this at all. I suspect that it has been made up, invented, and that it is a lie or a fib.

I'd like to also add the tongue-in-cheek jibe that there already is an extremist party that was voted into power at the last election that got less than 50% of the vote, namely the Conservative Party.
Baroness Sayeeda Warsi has consistently been the voice of No2AV and has said on a number of occasions that the British public will not understand the system. Does she mean to say that she considers the Great British public as being too stupid to understand the system? I wouldn't put that past her. One thing I haven't heard of is a proposal for a referendum to reform the House of Lords. If the Lords were elected who knows what sort of riff-raff would be voted into power?
We certainly wouldn't want a more democratic process now would we?

April 27, 2011

Horse 1181 - A Royal Mess-Up

The Chaser's coverage of the wedding of Prince William and Kate Middleton has been pulled by the Royal Family - details below:

http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2011/04/27/3201554.htm
Just two days before Prince William and Kate Middleton are due to tie the knot, ABC TV has been forced to cancel The Chaser's one-off live coverage of the event due to what it says are restrictions imposed by the royal family.
...
"Our obvious choice for a light-hearted commentary is The Chaser team. Clearly, the BBC and Clarence House have decided The Chaser aren't acceptable."

If The Royal Family or in this case their agents at Clarence House have made restrictions on what can be done with the coverage, then it would seem apparant they that have some degree over the control of that footage including things like TV rights and fees payable.

What I find particularly odd was this comment from The Chaser's producer Julian Morrow:

Morrow says the move goes against free speech.
"It seems a bit crazy for the royal family to be trying to dictate the way they get represented in the media," he said.

It must be said that the ABC is not the originator of the footage but is merely a purchaser of that footage. The originator, in this case The Royal Family and the BBC acting as agents, of course have the rights to decide what happens to that footage.

This sort of thing happens all the time with live broadcasts. For example:
http://abcnewsone.tv/?q=node/2199
This memorandum reviews the guidelines for allowable use of NFL game film or tape in regularly scheduled news programs, sports wrap-up shows and continuous loop news services.   Except as authorized in these Film/Tape Usage Guidelines, there can be no use of NFL game film or tape without NFL Films’ prior authorization.
This also happens with live coverage of Australia's AFL, the NRL, with highlights for the A-League, Formula One broadcasts, the English Premier League, the UEFA Champions League, the UEFA European Championships, the FIFA World cup... etcetera etcetera etcetera...

The fact that the Royal Family reserves the rights as to what may be done with the footage of what is to some degree a family event, is of no surprise to me whatsoever, and Mr Morrow's comments seem rather a bit churlish.

The Chaser by its nature is a progam which has been known to be in bad taste. No doubt they would try to finesse this under the veil of so called satire, but I think it's fairly obvious that from the outset, they'd be making sport of the Royal Family, and so I personally wonder if it is actually satire and not just a character hack fest.
The obvious solution if they wanted to go ahead with the program, would be to tell people to switch off the sound on their televisions and run the show on a short run ABC Digital station. ABC Grandstand 2 gets rebranded all the time as things like ABC Viva, ABC ANZAC, ABC Blues etc...

Not that I'd be watching or listening to their coverage anyway, because quite frankly I'd find the wedding a little dull to watch irrespective of who was taking over the top of the footage.

April 26, 2011

Horse 1180 - The Bottle Deposit

On Channel 9's sister station Go! (Sic), they have been showing re-runs of Seinfeld. On last night's episode which is from Season 7 entitled "The Bottle Deposit", Kramer and Newman embarked on a scheme to run bottles and cans for recycling from New York City to Michigan state to collect the 10 cent deposit on them. Kramer claims that he had tried it before but "couldn't crunch the numbers", whereas Newman claims that because as a mailman for the US Postal Service, that he can effectively run the scheme for free because there will be a surge of mail the week before Mother's Day, the "mother of all mail days".

I have "crunched the numbers" and have come up with the following:

The closest town in Michigan state to New York City in which the characters from Seinfeld live is a place called Temperance, MI. If Seinfeld, Kramer and Newman live at apartments 5A, 5B and 5F 181 West 81st St, New York City, then the distance which we have is 573 miles.

- If we take any normal car such as a Ford Focus then 30mpg (US) is pretty typical. To cover 573 miles would require 19.1 gallons of petrol (US).

- 19.1 gallons of petrol at a typical price for 1996 in which the episode was written would cost US$25.02.
- In order to make the scheme pay they would then need to drive back home across the same distance which would double the cost bringing the total cost to $50.04
- At a cost of $50.04 they would need to deliver 501 bottles to Temperance, MI to make the scheme pay.

There are two other things which can of course negated; namely:
1. Newman works for the US Postal Service and effectively has the truck for free, because he'd be paid to deliver mail anyway.
2. Kramer has been on strike from his job at the H&H Bagel factory for over a decade and therefore is wage would be nil.

Of course for most people these circumstances would most certainly come into play and therefore you would also need to factor in the fact that it would take about 20 hours to make the round trip, in which case it would probably just be easier to find regular employment.

However the point that Kramer makes that he "couldn't crunch the numbers" and neither could Newman,  simply just doesn't add up because anyone with a calculator and a Sixth Grade level of maths can work out the sums.

Or it could be that the writers of the show just assume that people are idiots, which is also a fair assumption.

April 25, 2011

Horse 1179 - Advance Australia Where?

The 25th of April is ANZAC Day which is a commemoration of arguably one of the most important dates in the forging of the identity of Australia as a nation. Tonight on ABC1 will be an episode of Q And A which asks another question of identity, which is whether or nor Australia needs to retain the monarchy. This in itself has been sparked by a Royal Wedding of someone who might not even end up being King of Australia if the pages and story of future history is written that way.

In research this I looked up the phrase "Republic of Australia" and actually came up with a fun result. I had made a blog post about this five years ago:
http://rollo75.blogspot.com/2006/03/horse-511-republic-of-australia.html
In principle my view hasn't changed at all in five years, but I'd thought I'd revisit this anyway.

The question of the monarchy or switiching to a republic is basically one of switching symbols and little else. Apart from this question I can see no logical argument which becomes the basis to make a change and if that's the only real basis, then as far as I'm concerned, it's very very very weak indeed.

The Commonwealth of Australia is a sovereign and independent nation. Since the last vestiges of rule from the United Kingdom were closed up with the Statute of Westminster 1931 (ratified in 1942), and the last few holes cleared up with regards the States and legal appeals to the Privy Council with the Australia Acts of 1986, there is absolutely no mechanism for either the parliament of the United Kingdom or the Queen herself, even if she did sit in her capacity as Queen of Australia, to pass, block or enact any laws in Australia at all.

Seeing as Australia is a sovereign and independent nation, then what possible benefits can we derive from becoming a republic? I can see precisely nil; in fact can see potential problems if we do.

If Australia does become a republic, then presumably there would be changes to the way the country is run. If a President is an elected official, them presumably this creates a mandate for them to exercise certain powers. The current Governor-General does have limited powers under the Constitution, but they have never been adequately defined and in my opinion nor should they be defined in future. The King–Byng Affair in Canada in 1926 and Australia's very own Constitutional Crisis in 1975 prove that the position of the Governor-General needs to be a fluid affair.

Currently Australia is viewed as a relatively small and harmless country, with left over cultural ties to the United Kingdom. I don't necessarily see anything wrong with that, though if Australia does become a republic, what sort of message does that send to the rest of the world?
Australia's biggest military ally over the past 60 odd years has been the United States; prior to this it was the United Kingdom. Does switching to a republic show the world that Australia as a nation is drifting towards the United States in terms of aspirations? If so, how does that affect the world's view of Australia? If we've seen especially over te past 10 years a general sort of animosity being shown to the United States and its foreign policy, does Australia realy need to throw its hat into that ring? I tend to think not.

If it is a matter of identity, then apart from military acheivements and defeats, Australia tends to define itself by its sporting acheivements. This is usually manifest on the cricket field, though the two brightest highlights that brought the nation together in my lifetime were probably Australia II winning the America's Cup and John Aloisi scoring the winning penalty in a shootout to send Australia to the World Cup for the first time in 32 years. In that respect, changing to a republic or keeping the monarchy is an enitrely irrelevant question.

Personally I would prefer that the country did nothing in moving towards becoming a republic. The system of government which we have in Australia has served us well for 110 years and I don't think we'd gain an iota by changing anything, but the potential to really foul things up is there. I don't see Canada or New Zealand particularly jumping at the chance to become a republic and I would suspect that the reasons are identical.

If anyone actually can come up with a plausible reason for making the switch, then I'd like to hear it. In fact I dare you to tell me. Maybe there's something I haven't thought of, but I doubt it.

April 23, 2011

Horse 1178 - Desperate People, Desperate Results

We have seen over the past few days at the Villawood Detention Centre, buildings razed to the ground, riots breaking out, the Federal Opposition pointing the blame at an "inadequate" government policy, and a Government which doesn't seem to have exhibited either a hard or a soft position on how to treat refugees or displaced persons.

There are a whole myriad of problems bound up with this and unravelling them is a difficult task at the best of times, so much so that it is little wonder that governments do not know what to do.

It is possible to end up with a situation where someone from Afghanistan who isn't being persecuted, crosses into Pakistan where they still will not be persecuted, takes passage into Malaysia where there still will not be persecuted, take a short journey to Indonesia where there still will not be persecuted and pay a people trafficker $10,000 plus to get onto a marginally seaworthy boat, and whilst on that boat dump their passports into the sea, when they will  be picked up by the Royal Australian Navy, sent to Christmas Island and then claim that they were persecuted and file for refugee status.

It is also possible for anyone within any of those countries (Pakistan, Malaysia and Indonesia) in the chain to also claim that they were originally from Afghanistan, whilst on that boat dump their passports into the sea and then be picked up by the Navy and then file for refugee status.

The thing is that  I don't doubt the desperation of any of these people.

If life is so terrible that you happen to think that it's a good idea to pay someone $10,000 plus to get onto a marginally seaworthy boat with the possibility of sinking and drowning on the passage to Australia, then by your actions you have pretty well much demonstrated that life must have been pretty bad to warrant doing this.

Of course this also happens to displace other genuine refugees from other parts of the world.

It should be obvious to anyone who even has a passing interest in the news that there are real humanitarian crises in Libya, the Sudan, Egypt, Syria, Tunisia, people who have otherwise been displaced by flooding in Pakistan, as well as other impending disasters like we have seen in Japan, Sri Lanka, Kashmir and Jammu, Singapore and China, all of which have an equally legitimate and equally desperate series of circumstances to claim refugee and/or displaced persons status over.

It's not that I discredit people who have obtained passage through the chain of the above events, but somewhere down the line there is a profitable business in trafficking people through dangerous waters in less than safe conditions.
It is not simply a matter of turning the boats around and sending them home, because if they've come from either Malaysia or Indonesia then they most certainly do not want the problem of dealing with people making undocumented migrations. 
It must be also said that all governments in the chain Afghanistan, Pakistan, Malaysia and Indonesia, probably view Australia as an easy target to send people on to, and thus Australia becomes the patsy of the region. This means to say that the Government of Australia and by inference the Australian Taxpayer because of reasons of fair play and decency gets taken advantage of. Surely someone must say that this is simply not right.

I have no problem with genuine refugees and displaced persons arriving on our shores and to be honest I would advocate a rise in the numbers which Australia would sign up to accept and accomodate under international treaties. People who have come from the worst of circumstances when they arrive in a new country, generally make a real go of life and contribute greatly to the country and the community, but just because people are desperate does not give people traffickers the right to profit from them and nor should it shift responsibilty onto a country which is quite frankly being taken for a ride.

Basically I think that what amounts to queue jumping offends my sense of fair play and I really don't want to blame desperate people who make those journeys, but people traffickers who do not play fair need to be dealt with somehow... as to how, that is more difficult and I don't know if the answer is all that easy to find.

April 20, 2011

Horse 1177 - Disabled Parking Cheats

One particular Saturday morning whilst in the carpark of a certain supermarket, I encountered a lurid orange notice which had fallen off of someone's car which read - Laziness Is Not A Disability.
I really love the idea of this. Although I don't have anyone in my family who suffers from a disability, it really gets my hackles up to see people parking in places that have been specifically set aside for those who are less mobile.

Suffice to say that I found a deeply amusing sense of joy and schadenfreude when this same car which was parked in that spot without a Mobility Parking Permit, encountered the wrath of the parking inspectors and had it's wheels clamped - Score!

Yesterday I saw something in Mosman equally disturbing. There was a red Jaguar XKR with a terribly pretentious number plate "JEDI" on it, which also bore a  Mobility Parking Permit.
Admittedly it is possible that the Permit was obtained legitimately, however I tend to doubt the likelihood of someone with genuine mobility issues stepping into and out of a very low slung sports car; especially condsidering that the owner of the vehicle was a man who was more orange than the contents of a Fanta can and was running to some vitally important business meeting.
Again I love the sense of justice that someone had, when on my way back from lunch the car had a message on an A4 sheet taped to the windscreen which said "Disability, claim you have. Lying I think you are." and a picture of the the ancient and revered Jedi Master Yoda underneath.
I sense balance is being restored to the force.

Life is already difficult enough for those people who have a disability of one sort or another. Just because you can't see it doesn't mean that it's not there; for that reason I think that a tremendous amount of restraint should be shown, because you simply don't know people's circumstances. However, when it is obvious that people are abusing the system, then I think that we should start brandishing our collective pointing finger of shame and say "SHAME ON YOU".

Now if I could just do something about the poxy BMWs and Mercs with those permits... there seems to be an inordinate amount of "disabled" people in Mosman. Well, people who have the permits anyway.

April 19, 2011

Horse 1176 - Imaginary #qanda

Last night the ABC had the gall to replace Four Corners, Media Watch and Q and A with a show called Paper Giants, which was a dramatisation of the story of Cleo magazine with Ita Buttrose, Frank and Kerry Packer. To be honest, I dismissed the series purely based on the adverts, and had no desire to watch it at all, so I didn't.

Faced with the prospect of having no Q and A to watch, I did what every person suffering from withdrawal symptoms upon seperation... I made do.

These then, for your amusement are my tweets from a purely Imaginary Q and A which for all sorts of reasons would have been utterly impossible. As we all know, Monday nights on the ABC were meant for yelling at the TV and sending off tweets... and fighting in the street, boy...

- Imaginary tonight causes imaginary outrage. I can't stand what the Deputy Leader of the Opposition, Arthur Fadden just said

- Someone needs to tell Ben Chifley that smoking a pipe even on Imaginary is bad for people's health.

- Ol' "Ming The Merciless" Menzies has got his scary eyebrows working tonight on Imaginary he wants to create some sort of Reserve Bank thing.

- Ha ha, PM Chifley thinks that the ABC might transmit this new fangled "television" thing - it'll never catch on - Imaginary

- But why would we even want to bother holding a referendum to ban Communists? Everyone knows that it would fail - Imaginary

- Now PM Chifley is talking about letting an American car company GM build cars in Australia. What a joke - Imaginary
 
- Artie Fadden calls Chifley a "socialist" for wanting to introduce the PBS - Imaginary


- PM Chifley wants a referendum to introduce Universal Health Care. Is this a s.51 amendment? - Imaginary

- Frankie Forde has been very quiet on tonight's Imaginary If he ever gets to be PM, he won't be around for very long

- Yeah, well we all remember what happpened two days after Jimmy Scullin became PM don't we? Fadden you are a dill - Imaginary

- Bla bla bla "light on the hill"... yeah Mr Chifley, more like bats in the belfry - Imaginary  

-  Can't say I feel sorry for the coal miners on strike. Maybe, Chifley should send in the troops? Ming aint helping much - Imaginary

Notwithstanding the fact that Forde was PM in 1945 (albeit for only 7 days), I would think that this set of tweets probably belongs within the period 1945-1949. I then got to wondering who would have hosted this episode of  Imaginary . I think in all likelihood it would have either been Alan McGilvray or perhaps more likely James Dibble. - go on click the link, you know you want to.

Out there in the twittersphere, other people were tweeting with the hashtag of #papergiants in place of the usual #qanda on a Monday night. I don't know what this says exactly, other than the Monday night #qanda crowd is a weird mob and really miss yelling at the TV.

April 18, 2011

Horse 1175 - The Falcon Is Replaceable

http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2011/04/15/3192034.htm?section=justin

With the news of Ford Australia laying off 240 workers from its Victorian manufacturing plants, I wonder if Ford are trying to give us subtle hints that the Falcon has had its days numbered.

The Sydney Morning Herald did a nice write up of the new Ford Territory and some of that is reproduced below:
http://smh.drive.com.au/motor-news/revealed-new-ford-territory-20110208-1albo.html
Revealed: New Ford Territory
Ford Australia has unveiled its new Territory it hopes can propel it back to the top of the SUV sales charts.
The local car maker's official pictures confirm the new look captured last month by Drive of a vehicle that will gain diesel power when it goes on sale in May.
It's seven years since the Territory was launched but Ford admits the new model is more of a "major update" than a next-generation vehicle.


The Ford Territory is essentially a Falcon derivative. It shares its 4L in-line six with the Falcon, however I think that it takes its four-wheel-drive system from the Lincoln-Mercury division of Ford in America.

What bothers me is the styling cues that Ford have chosen to give it:

Car manufacturers will try wherever possible to make their family of cars look similar. It actually helps with brand differentiation if you can share styling cues across the suite of vehicles.
Ford call their current design suite "Kinetic Design" and mainly features a largish, lower trapeziodal grille, with the headlights sort of stretched back into the front quarter panels. Admittedly this first appeared on the iOsis concept car and found its way onto the Mondeo, Focus and Fiesta but it's also starting to replace the 3-bar grille on the front of North American market cars.

Personally I think that the Territory is hinting at the replacement for the Falcon, which could be the Ford Taurus.

The last time that the nameplate Taurus appeared on a car in Australia, it was the unloved Fourth Generation car, which looked very swoopy and almost melty. The current Sixth Generation Ford Taurus if it was going to replace the Falcon would more or less be a perfect fit.

The 6th Gen Taurus sits on a Ford D3 platform which it shares with the current Volvo S60 and XC90. It was designed from the outset for both front-wheel-drive and four-wheel-drive configurations.
Underneath the bonnet the Taurus has a 3.5L V6 engine which puts out 263bhp or 200kW on the nose, which means that it does the triple act of getting more power, using less petrol and being a lighter car. The Falcon's in-line six which has a development stretching back to 1963, only puts out 255bhp or 195kW.

Ford also have the Territory covered with the Fifth generation Ford Explorer. It sits on Ford's D4 platform which is a slightly modfied D3, and pretty well much shares the same engine line up.

Maybe it's because Australia is so far away from everywhere else in the world that the car manufacturers have been so insular. My big fear is that if Ford decides to pull the pin on making cars in Australia that Toyota and Holden will follow suit. Increasingly Holden's need to exist is on the decline, and Toyota don't really need to produce cars here, so the latest movements from Ford I think are quite worrying.
There really isn't a good reason why Australia shouldn't be able to build cars, but there really isn't a good reason why we should either. If we don't think up a reason why we should and soon, then the Great God Dollar will decide for us.

April 15, 2011

Horse 1174 - The KFC Big Bash Needs To Be Hit For Six

I've read recently about the plans for the Twenty 20 Big Bash competition that will be starting up and to be honest, I'm about as enthused as that famous pig who "Got Up and Slowly Walked Away".

I understand the reasons for what essentially amounts to debranding the six state sides because that leaves the door open to "expand" the competition later, but is anyone truly going to even care that much in the first place?
I can see two fundamental problems with destroying and rebuilding the cricket competition in this way and these are outlined below.

1. The Example of The A-League.

I can see a very long future ahead of the A-League and yet it did do precisely what the Twenty 20 Big Bash proposes to do, however it had to do so because of very different circumstances.
The old National Soccer League was rife with clubs built on ethnic division and exclusiveness. There were Italian, Croatian, Greek, Serbian etc clubs all around the country. The few clubs which did break out this which were the Perth Glory, Northern Spirit and Parrmatta Power etc, but even they could not break the ethnic hold over the competition.

The new A-League might have started with 10 completely unethnically alinged clubs, but it did play on the old state rivalries. It is not by accident that Sydney FC plays in sky blue, or that Melbourne Victory plays in dark blue, Adelaide Utd in red or Queensland Roar in maroon. Perth kept it's purple because that was already an unethnically alinged clubs and fit the new paradigm of the A-League well.

The new Twenty 20 Big Bash does not do this. None of the proposed eight teams play in colours which mean anything to the cities they represent. The Sydney Sixers will play in pink and the Sydney Thunder will play in an electric green strip. Why? Certainly nobody is going to confuse them but the only things in cricket that pink symbolises for me is either the McGrath Foundation or the West Indies World Series Cricket strips of the late 1970s. Electric Green only reminds me of the Canberra Raiders or Kawasaki.

2. Go The "Generic-City Wildcats"!

What is the most famous team in the world across all sports? I bet that if you ask most people outside of the United States, then the answer will more than likely be Manchester United. The name Manchester United has nothing to do with being called a "City Something". They might be called the "Red Devils" as a nickname, but it does not form part of their name and nor does it matter either.

In fact right through Europe, football clubs are named not after their mascots but after the place where they come from. Liverpool, Arsenal, Real Madrid, Bayern Munich, are all named after the city they come from. In fact this used to be the way in Australia. Richmond, Essendon, Collingwood, South Sydney, Eastern Suburbs, Parramatta, never used to have a mascot officially in their names.

However when they did start to create mascots and nicknames, the reasons were almost always linked to either the cities they came from or their existing colours.

- Richmond is called the Tigers because they play in yellow and black.
- Essendon are named the bombers because of the former airport in the area.
- Collingwood are the magpies because they play in black and white.
- South Sydney wear red and green because of the colours of the waratah, and a named the Rabbitohs because during hard times, some of the players would sell rabbits as meat in the local area.
- Eastern Suburbs inherited both their "le tricolore" strip and the emblem of the Rooster from the touring French Rugby side of 1906. Easts defected to the new Rugby League in 1908.
- Parramatta gets its emblem from the name of the city itself. The Darug people called the area "Burramatta" which means "the place where the eels lie down".

The point is that neither the names Sydney Thunder nor Sydney Sixers or their pink and green strips respectively have anything to do with the city of Sydney at all. Part of the story of forming a new club unless it is being started by a bunch of friends or associates at a local level, is to reach out and connect with the area you're coming from.
Even the Gold Coast Suns which itself is a stupid name, tried to connect with the beachy sort of culture of the Gold Coast by playing in a red and yellow strip which is synonymous with the safety flags you'll find on most beaches in the country. In that respect the West Sydney Whatever-They-Are which will soon play in the AFL would have best played in black and red as a counter to the Swans white and red, and called themselves the Funnelwebs after Western Sydney's most famous residents. Black and red would have also connected the club to the club's first coach in Kevin Sheedy and thus told a story by itself.

That's really what naming a new sporting team is about. Starting any new sporting team is about starting a new story. Rivalries don't happen instantly but are woven into the fabric of that story over time. What I fear that the Twenty 20 Big Bash has done is by tearing the fabric away from the old stories of almost 120 years of cricket in Australia, it is very difficult to weave a new story afresh and that's bad for cricket.

April 13, 2011

Horse 1173 - Does Universal Healthcare Need to Even be a "Right" to Make it Sensible?

An objection which comes up quite commonly (and particularly by Americans) on forums which I frequent, is the argument that Health Care is not a "right", and therefore society shouldn't be forced to pay for it. I believe that it is this sort of attitude which has led the US Health Care system not only being the most expensive in the world to access, but also not particularly very good value for money either. The system appears to be driven by more greed, grift and corruption than an actual desire to a) create a working health care system and b) the actual health of people using it.
To subvert the question entirely, I pose a very different answer as to why a public health care system is a better option and it has nothing to do with it being a right or not.

Insurance itself is a monetary hedge against the risk of a contingent, uncertain loss. This implies a statistical risk which can be calculated and measured.

The Law of Large Numbers states that the more times you perform an experiment, then the average of those experiments will tend more towards either a theoretical or statistical average.
To wit, for a very large rolls of a die you should end up with the average ending up at about 3.5 (because (1+2+3+4+5+6)/6=3.5). Likewise, if you take a very large sample size for other events, the more times you repeat the experiment then the closer you get to the theoretical or statistical average.

For a population of people, the statistical average for something medically bad happening to them (which is why you take out insurance in the first place) tends towards the statistical average for something medically bad happening to them with an ever increasing sample size.
Since the entire population is also equal to the the entire sample size, then the statistical average for something happening, is also equal to the statistical average for something happening (unity equals unity).
Therefore from a statistical standpoint, the best sample size on which to base and charge your insurance coverage, is obviously the entire population. It follows that Risk is best spread over the entire population on this basis (you can of course do a reiterative calculation on this or perhaps a differential calculus equation, however I find that this tends to cloud the issues somewhat).


There is a problem though:
The population itself isn't uniform. There are older people and younger people. The chance of a 21 year old person suffering from an age related cancer, is not as high as a 74 year old. Also the chance of a 83 year old lady being in a serious motor accident is not as high as a 24 year old male.

It follows that the people who would want to buy insurance are also the same people most likely to drain the pool of funds. From the insurance organisation's point of view, this poses a problem. If younger people are less likely to pay into the fund and older people are more likely to draw from it, then the premiums must be invariably higher than if everyone had been paying into the fund in the first place.

Insurance by its nature suffers from negative self-selection for the above reasons. The best way to avoid this is to spread selection of payers over the widest possible base. Since the widest possible base is in fact the entire population, then for this reason the best possible selection system is also the entire population.
In theory the best possible payers into the system are those people who are also least likely to want to claim from it because it helps to spread the risk (which is after all they very point of an insurance question).


There is also the issue of "economies" of scale at play, at which the factors that cause a producer’s average cost per unit to fall as the scale of output is increased. Admittedly, this doesn't always line up with the general practice but seeing as the idea of universal health care creates a Natural Monopoly, coupled with the fact that not everyone is actually using the system at once, does then to ameliorate it somewhat.

Those same people who usually denounce the idea of Universal Health Care usually also forget that it was Sir Winston Churchill who first publicly declared the idea of Universal Health Care to the members of Royal College of Physicians in London in March '44:
The discoveries of healing science must be the inheritance of all. That is clear. Disease must be attacked, whether it occurs in the poorest or the richest man or woman simply on the ground that it is the enemy; and it must be attacked just in the same way as the fire brigade will give its full assistance to the humblest cottage as readily as to the most important mansion. Our policy is to create a national health service in order to ensure that everybody in the country, irrespective of means, age, sex, or occupation, shall have equal opportunities to benefit from the best and most up-to-date medical and allied services available.
Obviously to come to such an opinion, Churchill must at some point have witnessed first hand the terrible suffering of people who had been injured during the Second World War. To make an "Big C Tory" come to such a conclusion must have required a situation so bad that it crossed all ideologies. Also remember that death, disease and injury respects no class, rank, or other social barriers.


Even if you allow for the "free rider problem"* (look it up you'll learn something), even Churchill realised that allowing dignity to all members in society was a far better outcome than having people excluded from the system because they couldn't afford it.

Or maybe you would prefer that people don't have decent health care, so long as their dignity doesn't impinge on your precious rights:
If they would rather die, they had better do it, and decrease the surplus population.
- Scrooge, A Christmas Carol, Charles Dickens (1843).

However setting this aside for a moment, it is very easy to draw a connection between the degradation of a working population even if you morally reduce them to little more than units of labour and Frédéric Bastiat's Parable of the Broken Window. It stands to reason that if the working units of labour are generally allowed to degrade through sickness and/or injury, then the overall utility of those units of labour decreases and hence the overall incomes of the nation falls; therefore not in a economic sense beneficial to withhold or deny the provision of health care to the working populace.

It is mainly for the reasons of the net insurance benefit, that extending the provision of health care on a universal basis, that people who deny that health care is a right should look at. Though if you really want include some sort of moral dimension, perhaps we should look at something else which Sir Winston Churchill said:
The inherent vice of capitalism is the unequal sharing of blessings; the inherent virtue of socialism is the equal sharing of miseries.
Maybe that is the crux of people's reasoning. Maybe they actually like to see people miserable.


*The Free Rider Problem. In a civilised and sensible society, we choose to value people 's dignity and are prepared to accept this cost.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_rider_problem

April 12, 2011

Horse 1172 - No 2 AV - revisited

In Horse 1170 I argued that the "No 2 AV" campaign is a silly proposal because it is seemingly based on falsehoods.
Over the past few days though and as the impending referendum draws closer, it would appear that the Tories are stepping up their campaign backing "No 2 AV".

I found two snippets from the media most interesting. Both of the people in question appear to be blissfully ignorant of the circumstances which placed them into the positions which they now hold.

Firstly the UK's PM, David Cameron:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-13039687
David Cameron has branded the alternative vote system "undemocratic" and "unfair" and urged people to oppose it in next month's referendum.
...
"It's a system - AV - so undemocratic that you can vote for a mainstream party just once, whereas someone can vote for a fringe party like the BNP and it's counted three times... It's so unfair that the candidates who come second or third can end up winning."

I don't think that Mr Cameron is in any sort of position to be arguing over what is and isn't "democratic" considering the method which he came to be the Prime Minister in the first place.

During the General Election of 2010, only 65.1% of the population bothered to show up at the polls. If you look at just the numbers of raw votes across the country, the Tories achieved 36.1% of the total vote. This means that of the total population of the UK, the Prime Minister was installed on just 23½% of the population's votes. This means that more than three quarters of the population either didn't vote for a Tory government or didn't vote at all. How "democratic" is that I ask you?
Of course it could be argued that when a coalition was formed with the LibDems, that their proportion of the vote should be included. On those figues including the 23% of the total which the LibDems gained, you still only get about 38½% of the vote which is still less than a majority of elligible voters.

Actually if you look on a seat by seat basis, then more than two-thirds of all sitting members actually came to occupy their seat on less than a third of the vote. Again I ask, "how democratic" is that?

The other worrying thing I find with Mr Cameron's statement is that somehow he seems to be perfectly fine with ignoring or deliberately trampling on the voices of 12% of the electorate.
It is true that I might not particularly like the BNP, UKIP or the National Front but I still don't think that their voices should not be heard; in fact I endorse their rights under the Bill of Rights Act 1689 etc, to their right to have a say in the political discussion of the nation (and be judged on what they say). Moreover, there are all sorts of voices which under the current system don't even shape the political discussion of the nation. There are plenty of Social Democrat, Socialist, Unionist, Green and otherwise smaller parties which I imagine which Mr Cameron would consider to be "the fringe". Does Mr Cameron that their voices should also be trampled or extinguished?
By including those parties on the ballot paper and giving people a preference, people can go to the polls and actively vote for parties which they know will lose. However, because primary votes are counted and published, the dialogue which the ballot papers actually tell the major political parties is of far wider scope than the FPTP system can ever allow. Besides which, in a democracy all voices no matter how "looney" they are have the right to be heard. Considering the horrendous parliamentary expenses scandals which had occurred in 2009, quite frankly both Labor and the Tories need a swift kick up the backside.

As for the AV system being "undemocratic", perhaps Mr Cameron should take a look at the data complied by the Economist Intelligence Unit of The Economist Group:
http://graphics.eiu.com/PDF/Democracy_Index_2010_web.pdf
If the Australian system is so "undemocratic" then how is it that Australia which uses a form preferential voting system, is able to outscore the UK on the EIU's "Democracy Index" by 13 places? We are only behind Norway, Iceland, Denmark, Sweden and New Zealand.
Well?

The absolute prize piece of idiocy which I found, I came acrooss via a link from of Antony Green from the ABC

The link provided was from Michael Ashcroft or rather Lord Ashcroft KCMG.

http://conservativehome.blogs.com/platform/2011/04/lord-ashcroft-fairer-votes-remember-tiger-hewson.html
Proponents of AV would say that a majority of voters did not want Mountford. But it is also clear that many more wanted Mountford than any other candidate. What kind of mandate did the MP have, being the first choice of barely one-sixth of the electorate? I leave it to others to decide whether the outcome was "fairer" than would have been the case if only first preferences had counted.

In answer to Lord Ashcroft's comment, then yes the outcome was fairer because an AV system was been in place. If the majority of voters don't want a candidate, then how is that possibly fairer? If the majority of people vote against something as might have been the case of the 2010 General Election and an underlying reason why people voted for the LibDems, then that should have said something very profound indeed.

Also, this whole piece is bit rich coming from a member of the House of Lords. The House of Lords is an unelected body of which the sitting members are appointed rather than elected. How many people voted for Lord Ashcroft I ask you? ZERO.

Not a single person voted to put Lord Ashcroft into the House of Lords and yet he is charged with the responsibility of voting on legislation in the upper house what supposedly is a more democractic system than one voted by the preferential vote, on his logic.

<><><><>

As this campaign wears on, the more I am convinced that living in Australia, we happen to have what is probably the best and most robust parliamentary democracy in the world. I think a great deal of that is because that more voices are heard through the ballot box, and parties tend to adjust their policies for a wider audience. I'm sure that the preferential voting system we have is a great contributor in that.